Democrats won elections across the nation last week and in many states that had been solidly Republican for a generation or more. For instance, Democrats won every state-wide election in Texas. Texas!
The biggest winners of the day might be pollsters who were predicting something like this. If anything, they didn’t predict a big enough wave.
There are two things to think about after an election, but especially after such a dramatic win. First, what is the significance of the election for the personnel involved, both newly elected officials and in future races? Second, what is the electorate trying to tell the politicians? This last issue is especially difficult, so I won’t try to make definitive statements.
People New to Office
In such a wave there will be people elected to office who have never been elected to anything before. Three Democratic senators did just that: Annie Andrews from South Carolina, Adam Hamilton from Kansas, and Abdul el-Sayed in Michigan. That is a remarkable achievement, but it is going to be a real challenge for each of them.
They will have to hire staff for their home states as well as staff in DC. They will need to find a place to live in DC and sort out all the logistics with their families. In the Senate, they will have to learn the rules of speaking, how to vote, what the committee structure is, and how to comport themselves in these settings. This is not easy.
The Senate has several rules to encourage collegiality, and seniority plays a large role in the assignment of tasks. Junior senators are at the bottom of the pecking order and are expected to be seen and not heard. That will be hard to swallow for some of these people who have just come off a big win.
The other thing to watch is how this affects the race to be the presidential nominee of each party. Someone with the media presence of el-Sayed could be a kingmaker in the nomination. On the other side, the only bright spot for Republicans in the country was the state of Florida. Does that help Gov. Desantis?
One thing is clear, the race for the nomination in both parties started on Wednesday.
Is There a Mandate?
Elected officials often claim to have a mandate, that is, a charge from the electorate to do something specific. This is especially tempting when there is such a big wave as we just had. The problem is that it is really unclear what the mandate might be, and even if there is one.
For example, most exit polls showed that the biggest issues for voters included the price of gas and the general expense of everything in their lives. The war in Iraq was also a concern, although the war and expenses (especially the price of gas) are connected in most people’s minds. But a lot of people who voted for Trump before are very upset about yet another war in the Middle East.
This would suggest that the Democrats have a mandate to pass legislation on anything people find too expensive, like gas, healthcare, food, etc. But a lot of Trump voters did switch precisely because of the war. What issues will Democrats focus on?
Comments at victory speeches and the like suggest that the Democrats think they have a mandate to do things not on that list. For instance, Ro Khanna, a House member from California and prominent Democrat, immediately said that “DEI is back.” I don’t remember that being a big issue in the campaign.
Another significant topic is the Electoral Vote Compact. A group of states (almost all run by Democrats) have agreed to all assign their electoral college votes in a presidential election to the candidate that wins the popular vote, not according to which candidate won their state. Part of the agreement is that this will take effect when their electoral votes pass the 270 threshold. Well, there are now enough states with Democratic governors and legislators that several new states could join, and this would become a reality. No one talked about this on the campaign.
It is also widely assumed that the Democratic House will begin impeachment hearings on the President and any number of his Cabinet members. Did people vote for this? Some did, but probably not the swing voters who made the difference in this election. And since a conviction in the Senate requires 2/3 or 67 senators, this isn’t going to go anywhere.
Every party is tempted to think that the mandate they were given by the electorate is to do all the things their most committed followers want. This leads them to overreach and alienate the voters they just won.
The Democrats are in an interesting position. They now control both houses of Congress for the remainder of Trump’s term in office. When he was first elected ten years ago, Trump faced the same scenario. At his first meeting with Sen. Schumer and Rep. Pelosi, he signaled that he was willing to work with them. He was all about making deals, remember. They came out of the meeting a little shocked and, from what I remember, a little excited. But their supporters were horrified. Democratic leaders were not going to be allowed to work with him at all.
In an interview with Ross Douthat on Sunday night, the President made another overture to the Democrats. He said he would be willing to make a deal on immigration, perhaps legalizing millions of people here illegally. This is the same issue Schumer and Pelosi were surprised about. I don’t think anything will come of it for the same reasons.
If they are disciplined, Democrats could get a lot done. I saw one suggestion that they pass the most radical leftwing bills imaginable but title them something like “The Donald Trump is the Greatest President in History Act.” He would never veto anything with a name like that. But would they try it? Never.
Polarization
We hear a lot about polarization, the idea that the country has congealed into two opposing factions. This latest election suggests that isn’t true. Not only did a lot of people switch from voting for Republicans to voting for Democrats, but a lot of ballot initiatives passed in direct opposition of the officials who won.
For instance, in Washington State, a ballot initiative won that will keep boys out of girls’ sports. But the most left-wing officials were elected at the same time in the state. In North Carolina and Ohio, where Democrats won both Senate seats, voter ID measures passed (a typically Republican issue). North Carolina is particularly interesting because the Democrat won the senate 58.7% to 39.1% but voter ID won 60% to 40%, almost exactly the opposite.
What this suggests is that the electorate is less polarized than the parties, which should not be surprising. But it also suggests that the parties, even when they win in a landslide, may not have the mandate they think they do. Will Roy Cooper, the new Democratic Senator from North Carolina, vote for the SAVE Act, which would require voter ID nationwide? Probably not, even though 60% of the state that just elected him to office voted for it. This suggests that there is a real misalignment.
Last week’s Israeli election and this week’s American election highlight the differences in different electoral systems. With the many, many parties in Israel, misalignment is difficult. If you can’t find a party that exactly lines up with you, start one. With only two parties here, misalignment is almost guaranteed. In Israel, forming a government after the election is very difficult. They still don’t have one. Here it is easy, although the results of the election, the swearing in and seating of the new congress, will not happen for two months.
The American government is in a strange place right now. The Congress elected two years ago in which the Republicans are the majority still has two months in office. The one just elected, where the Democrats are the majority, will not convene until January. The Republican majorities could pass a lot of legislation in that time. This is just another peculiarity of the system.
